Madden: When a Movie Star's Persona and a Sports Legend's Don't Exactly Mesh Onscreen

By Jim Slotek

Rating: C-

Even if Prime Video’s Madden wasn’t one of the worst sports movies on every other level, it would still be sunk by the much-talked-about casting of Nicolas Cage as the loudly affable NFL coach/broadcaster/video-game legend John Madden.

When it was announced, it flummoxed Cage fans (of which I am one) and football fans, though, in true fan style, the reaction was often an optimistic, “Who knows? It just might work.”

Spoiler alert: It doesn’t.

Cage has one of the most distinctive voices in Hollywood. Madden’s is arguably the most recognizable voice in football history. They neither look nor sound like each other, and have both been parodied by many comic impressionists. A lot of latex and padding, and every ounce of acting ability Cage possesses couldn’t overcome that reality. He’s the star of the movie, and almost every second he’s onscreen he takes you out of it.

(It also had me thinking, has Nicolas Cage sounded like Nicolas Cage in every movie he’s ever made?  That’s not necessarily a bad thing, but it could explain this misguided acting challenge.)

There are moments, particularly when Madden makes his NFL broadcasting debut, when there’s a hint of the foghorn-voiced savant buffoonery that made Madden so popular. But it says something that Kathryn Hahn, who plays Madden’s wife Virginia, does a better John Madden impression than Cage in a scene where she mocks her husband.

Other name actors play famous people in Madden. But who remembers Oakland Raiders’ owner Al Davis well enough to say whether Christian Bale’s depiction of him is accurate? Or whether comedian John Mulaney has captured the essence of EA Games founder Trip Hawkins, the man who oversaw the creation of Madden NFL, one of the most popular video game franchises in history?

David O. Russell directs a chronologically told, superficially presented depiction of Madden’s life. It starts where most sports movies end, with a championship (a Super Bowl won by the Raiders under Coach Madden). And it contains a rare moment where the movie rises above ground-level creatively. As the Vince Lombardi Trophy waits, we see “inside” Madden’s head, as the Xs and Os of a planned play assemble – a precursor to the crayon-like video Telestrator that would be Madden’s trademark when he transitioned from coach to breathlessly enthusiastic colour commentator.

Madden is presented in three obvious acts, that could have more imaginatively played out of order with flashbacks. There’s Coach Madden, then the TV Madden, and then the video game Madden. The script tries to squeeze in everything it can in as short a time as possible, as when the Raiders’ Jack Tatum hit New England’s Darryl Stingley so hard he paralyzed him for life. That incident could be a movie in itself, but it consists of about a minute of Davis and Madden encouraging a guilt-ridden Tatum to get over it.

Prime execs apparently caught on early that they had a stinker, with a $70 million budget on their hands. The “theatrical release” was as limited and short as possible (it never was released in Canada).

And though that release occurred last week as Mulaney hosted Saturday Night Live - which John Madden himself did 44 years earlier – Mulaney did not mention the movie in his monologue.

Madden. Directed by David O. Russell. Stars Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn. Now streaming on Prime Video.