Starsuckers: A 'Ripping' Butler Brothers Feature at the Blood in the Snow Festival
By Thom Ernst
Rating: B
We've reached the point where the announcement of a new Butler Brothers film is reason enough for anticipation. Starsuckers is that film.
After a remarkably successful run at horror and fantasy festivals around the world, Starsuckers comes home to Toronto for the Blood in the Snow Film Festival. It's a homecoming worth attending. Brett and Jason Butler and Blood in the Snow are as Canadian as orange-coloured cheddar cheese.
With the needle pointing somewhere to the left of weird, a Butler Brothers film like First Round Down or Mourning Has Broken thrives on subverting expectations they've already subverted. Their films, and Starsuckers is no exception, check every box in the horror and fantasy playbook. They then tip the whole thing over until the contents tumble into something resembling organized chaos.
Eileen (Jersey Anderson) redefines the word “starstruck” in Starsuckers.
It's an approach that goes well beyond farce, fuelled by a fierce dedication to doing things their own way.
Chuck and Eileen (Jacob Stickles and Jersey Anderson) are a naively endearing couple, traumatized by a series of miscarriages and the slow erosion of hope. Life takes on new purpose when their celebrity idols, Bjorg and Sasha (James Alex, Manon Ens-Lapointe), invite them to a secluded Northern Ontario getaway for a little spiritual and physical re-tuning.
Without hesitation, Chuck, who can quote the one-upmanship zingers from Bjorg's every C-level action film, and Eileen, who puts drops of Sasha's packaged tears into her own eyes, head off into seclusion.
But where they're heading is straight into Butler country. You won't find it by following traditional routes. You get there when your GPS is hijacked by some subversive faction of the government whose idea of research is to fuck with reality just to see what happens.
Starsuckers exists on that plane and is, indeed, a worthy study in perverse human interaction. And while there's no shortage of films exploring the horrors of celebrity, Starsuckers twists the narrative to play both sides of the coin, revealing a kind of celebrity worship that results in a spectacular rupture of self-awareness.
Bjorg has a grandiose misconception of his own celebrity status, which Chuck is only too happy to validate, while Sasha has bought into her own publicity as a legitimate mystical healer. On the other side are Chuck and Eileen, both willing to kowtow to their hosts' increasingly bizarre demands in exchange for the privilege of being accepted.
It's all hijinks and dark humour until things congeal into a bloody, muscle-ripping calamity. But who's kidding whom? Even the muscle-ripping is funny.
Starsuckers feels like a turning point in the Butler Brothers' filmmaking. There's a greater sense of control here than we've seen in their past films, particularly in the dialogue, which carries its own peculiar authority. Amid the double entendres and sexual references - of which there are plenty - Starsuckers builds a universe with its own brand of pop-culture references and philosophical pretensions. And no matter how far the film ventures into absurdity, or how extreme the action becomes, the characters never behave in ways that betray who they are.
Cinematographer Mathieu Seguin deserves particular recognition for erasing the visual divide that so often separates low-budget independent filmmaking from its better-funded commercial counterparts. There's nothing about Starsuckers' visual presentation that asks the audience to make allowances for its budget.
Starsuckers was filmed in Sudbury, Ontario, with an entirely local crew, which may account, at least in part, for the film's distinctive look. Perhaps the crew's familiarity with the terrain helped capture the brightly coloured vistas of Northern Ontario, where even the interiors of homes and cabins seem to breathe in the northern air.
"I love being surrounded by all this wood!" Bjorg effuses, soaking up the atmosphere of a lakefront cabin. "Wood" tends to be one of the frequent words Bjorg uses referencing more than just trees and building material: It's encouraging to see the Butler Brothers becoming increasingly accomplished filmmakers without showing any inclinations in becoming more respectable ones.
It's good to know that the Blood in the Snow Film Festival (BITS to the initiated) has been part of Toronto's film festival scene for 15 years. That's 15 years of showcasing independent Canadian horror, from first-time directors to seasoned auteurs. Festival founder Kelly Michael Stewart has led the BITS team in uncovering some of the most obscure, strange and engaging horror talent Canada has on offer.
Past festivals have introduced audiences to gems like Beyond the Black Rainbow (2012), the criminally underseen thriller Fugue (2018), She Who Must Burn (2015), Dark Match (2024), Scared Shitless (2024), and a few personal favourites, including the must-see Vicious Fun (2021) and the low-budget slasher throwback Secret Santa (2015).
As for recommendations to see this year? Personally, I don't risk missing out on any. Six days of horror? I tend to see them all.
Starsuckers, is directed by Brett and Jason Butler and stars, Jacob Stickles, Jersey Anderson, James Alex, Manon Ens-Lapointe and Stephen Hobe. Starsuckers screens at 9:30 p.m. Thursday, November 19 at the Isabel Bader Theatre, as part of the Blood in the Snow film Festival
The Blood in the Snow Film Festival runs from Monday, November 16 to Saturday, November 21. All screenings are at the Isabel Bader Theatre.