Elsinore: Andrew Scott Soars in True Story of Actor’s Heroic Battle to Play Hamlet
By Karen Gordon
Rating: A
At the heart of Elsinore is a breathtakingly gorgeous performance from Andrew Scott. That alone is enough reason to get thee to the cinema to see this film — especially if thee doth delight in following yon Oscar nominations for which Scott, as Hamlet, will surely acquire in the eyes of this poor scribe. Happily, wrapped around him is a movie that is exhilarating, wistful, and heartbreaking.
Elsinore is based on a true story: the last year in the life of accomplished and acclaimed Scottish actor Ian Charleson (Scott), who died of AIDS in 1990. He spent that year fighting for his life while preparing for the hugely demanding role of Hamlet at the vaunted National Theatre in London. He completed 24 glorious performances before becoming was too weak to continue. It’s worth knowing that his performance is still considered one of best — if not the best — in modern theatre history.
Elsinore is about a man passionately embracing life in the face of death. Working from a script by writer Stephen Beresford, director Simon Stone (The Dig) and his formidable cast pour heart and vitality into an elegiac film that is as beautiful as it is tragic.
And if you’ll forgive me for continuing with the clichés, it’s also a film that speaks to the invigorating, life-affirming effect of making and sharing art, theatre in particular, that is immediate, intimate, and meaningful.
It also calls us back to the AIDS era when gay men, heavily stigmatized because of the disease, stayed in the closet, and when AIDS ripped through the arts community, things that must not be forgotten.
Charleson is best known to moviegoers for his role in 1981’s Oscar-winning film Chariots of Fire, which he followed up with Gandhi (1982). After those major films, the expected career of movie stardom didn’t materialize, something that nags at him. He had other work on television and on stage but yearns for a meaty role.
Charleson is having dinner at home with close friends including casting agent Patsy Pollock (Billie Piper). The vaunted National Theatre has just opened Hamlet with Daniel Day-Lewis as the lead. The role, he says, is the greatest part that you can play, being performed in the greatest theatre. Charleson expresses jealousy.
Then fate intervenes. When Day-Lewis abruptly leaves the production, the National’s director Richard Eyre (a wonderful Johnny Flynn) hires Charleson. But here’s the rub. Charleson, still in the closet, is HIV-positive. He has kept that a secret from all but his closest friends, but reveals it to Eyre, a mark of his integrity. Hamlet is a physically demanding role, and he assures Eyre that he is healthy enough to take it on. They dive into rehearsals.
Unfortunately, Charleson’s health changes abruptly, and his HIV turns into full-blown AIDS. Charleson is once again honest with Eyre but doesn’t want to quit and wants to keep his health problems a secret even from the cast. He promises to keep himself in shape.
To that end, he enlists esteemed AIDS researcher Dr. Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman) at the best clinic in London. But she has no good news for him. She wants him to step away from the role. Charleson refuses.
Over the course of the film Charleson undergoes treatments, rehearses, almost dies and then recovers. He looks to friends, some of whom, like Patsy, fiercely support him when he says he wants to keep going despite how weak he has become. To others, he rationalizes why he won’t quit and won’t go public with any of his secrets. He comforts dying friends and comes clean to his mother and father. Ultimately, he takes the stage at the National Theatre as Hamlet.
That means we get Scott — one of the most gifted and empathetic actors working in film today — as Charleson, the actor, fighter, friend, son… as Hamlet.
Elsinore is first and foremost the story of Charleson’s refusal to give in to a disease that was ravaging and slowly killing him, effectively an ode to his passion for his vocation. And it’s a film that makes us feel the vitality of the theatre. In a sense, the film gives Charleson the movie stardom that eluded him in real life.
The story of his illness would be enough, but Beresford's script is even richer. It observes the relationships of the people around Charleson that are brought into sharper focus by the ticking of the clock and the inevitability of what is happening to him. This isn't a flashy movie; it’s grounded and on a human scale. But it is not a funeral march.
Stone finds a tone that doesn’t diminish the trajectory of Charleson’s illness. He keeps the movie moving, then stands back and lets his brilliant leading man break our hearts.
Elsinore. Directed by Simon Stone. Written by Stephen Beresford. Starring Andrew Scott, Billie Piper, Johnny Flynn, and Olivia Colman. In theatres November 20.