Paper Tiger: Russian Mob v American Family Drama Has Moments, Just Too Few

By Chris Knight

Rating: B

I admire the dry, sometimes stilted formalism of writer-director James Gray, but wouldn’t count myself a fan. Whenever a new project comes along, my reaction is less an exuberant “ooh boy!” than a cautious “What’s he done this time?”

With Paper Tiger, it turns out he’s done another American period piece. Ditching the science fiction of 2019’s Ad Astra and the Edwardian jungle adventure of 2016’s The Lost City of Z, he’s instead created a thematic sequel to his last film, Armageddon Time, which was a coming-of-age drama set in Queens. 

Miles Teller is a family man trying to settle a Russian mob debt in Paper Tiger.

That one was set in 1980 on the cusp of the Reagan years. Paper Tiger moves us six years later and deep into that heady, greedy era.

Irwin Pearl (Miles Teller wearing Richard Dreyfuss’s glasses) is an engineer raising two sons, Scott and Ben, with his wife Hester (a distractingly frumpified Scarlett Johansson). Money is tight and the kids are nearing university age, but Irwin’s flash brother Gary (Adam Driver) has a plan.

Seems New York is being overrun with Russians fleeing Communism. (If only they knew it had just a few more years left to run.) Enthusiastic but unschooled, these immigrants are looking to set up businesses but need local help, which is where the Pearl brothers come in. Gary, an ex-cop, has connections. Irwin has expertise and regulatory knowhow.

He’s also naive as a rock. The Russians they connect with are clearly nogoodniks, but Irwin treats them like friendly business colleagues, even bringing his sons with him on a late-night visit to a work site. What could go wrong?

Gray creates an odd fission in the plot. One fork finds Irwin accidentally antagonizing the skittish Russians, who respond with threats and worse. But at the same time, Hester is experiencing vision problems, and takes herself to the doctor, where she gets a dire diagnosis that she decides not to share with her husband.

It’s not difficult keeping these two threads separate in your mind; the issue is trying to figure out why they’re not more intertwined in the screenplay. You could split the couple’s problems into a pair of separate movies, but Gray is intent on letting them battle it out for narrative supremacy in this one.

Irwin’s gets a little more screen time and is thus the de facto winner. It also helps that his is the subplot featuring Driver, who is far and away the strongest character in the movie. His whole former-cop thing (I don’t think we ever find out why he left the force) makes him an object of interest to audience members and fellow characters alike, and the least predictable force on the screen.

That’s fascinating for as far as it goes, but it doesn’t go far enough. There’s a fantastic shootout scene late in the film that uses camera and sound to the max, and feels like a lost reel from the American New Wave of that time.

I wish the film could have maintained that level of pacing and expertise throughout. But in the end, Paper Tiger folds.

Paper Tiger. Directed by James Gray. Starring Adam Driver, Miles Teller, and Scarlett Johansson. In theatres November 20.